Welcome to Stacy's Treats

Indulge in our delectable cakes, cookies and desserts, handcrafted with love and the finest ingredients

Serving the Erie, Pennsylvania area since 2023

Image of Oreo (chocolate ganache icing)Image of OreoImage of Red Velvet (cream cheese icing)Image of Coconut CreamImage of Strawberry Cream CheeseImage of Peppermint BarkImage of Strawberry PretzelImage of Triple Chocolate Raspberry (chocolate ganache)Image of Chocolate No-BakeImage of Mississippi MudImage of Oreo (chocolate ganache icing)Image of OreoImage of Red Velvet (cream cheese icing)Image of Coconut CreamImage of Strawberry Cream CheeseImage of Peppermint BarkImage of Strawberry PretzelImage of Triple Chocolate Raspberry (chocolate ganache)Image of Chocolate No-BakeImage of Mississippi Mud

Features

Image of Black Forest (whipped icing)

Custom Cakes

Specializing in custom cakes for all occasions

Fresh Baked Cookies

Handcrafted cookies in a variety of flavors

Specialty Desserts

Indulgent desserts made with the finest ingredients

Restaurant Orders

Let us make your restaurant's desserts

Testimonials

Image of Irene Johnson

Irene Johnson

Happy Customer

I ordered a custom cake for my daughter's birthday, and it was absolutely delicious! The design was exactly what I wanted, and the taste was even better. Thank you!

Image of Pam Stalmore

Pam Stalmore

Happy Customer

Stacy's cookies and cakes are truly exceptional. The variety is great, from classic chocolate chip to unique seasonal options, and you can tell they use high-quality ingredients. I highly recommend Stacy's Treats to anyone looking for a delicious, homemade indulgence!

Image of Michael Reynolds

Michael Reynolds

Happy Customer

I recently ordered from Stacy's Treats, and I couldn’t be happier with my experience! The cookies were reasonably priced, incredibly fresh, and delicious. It’s clear that a lot of love and attention to detail goes into every item. The owner was friendly and accommodating, making the whole process smooth and enjoyable.

Image of Emily Carter

Emily Carter

Happy Customer

The cookies, cakes, and pies are not only beautifully made but also full of flavor and made with love and care. The owner is incredibly nice and attentive, ensuring my order was customized to my preferences. It’s wonderful to support a local, home-based business that delivers such high-quality, fresh products. I highly recommend their baked goods to anyone looking for a sweet, homemade treat.

Contact Us

We are available for any inquiries or custom orders.

Have a question or want to place an order? Reach out to us!